Karen Read and John O’Keefe: Inside evolution of Boston murder mystery since mistrial

Karen Learn, the lady who was accused of killing her Boston Cop -friend throughout a Nor’Aller in January, will likely be tried for the second time this week after her first persecution ended with a hung jury.

Learn, 45, is accused of second -degree homicide, manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly accident in reference to the dying of John O’Keefe on January 29, 2022. He was 46 and located within the snow outdoors the home of one other police officer. Hours after a bunch of individuals went there for an after social gathering to have an evening drink.

It was initially accused of manslaughter-typical in a deadly hit-and-run case-but the authorities later tackled the indictment for homicide.

Karen Learn Replace: Fireplace Lead Investigator on witness record for the 2nd trial interval within the dying of Boston Cop John O’Keefe

Karen Learn and John O’Keefe are proven in an undated household photograph. Learn is accused of beating him along with her SUV after an evening of consuming, however her protection has argued that she will likely be framed by a bunch of his former police colleagues. (Courtesy of Karen Learn)

Throughout her first course of and in a number of media interviews afterwards, she maintained her innocence and claimed that another person killed O’Keefe.

Do you could have a brand new dip? Click on right here

Joseph Giacalone, a former NYPD sergeant and a professor of felony regulation to Penn-Lehigh Valley, advised Fox Information Digital that he thinks that prosecutors may have a tough time getting a conviction after the primary case had fallen aside.

Within the first check, accusations of a police cowl, the arrest of a web-based blogger who was accused of intimidating witnesses, the resignation of the principle investigator and chronic questions have been about how O’Keefe died.

The waterfall bar and grille are proven in Canton, Massachusetts, on March 29, 2025. That is the place Karen Learn, John O’Keefe, Jennifer McCabe and pals visited earlier than O’Keefe’s Loss of life in January 2022. (Richard Beetham for Fox Information Digital)

Karen Learn’s 2nd homicide course of that begins within the dying of boyfriend Cop: what to know

Officers of Justice declare that learn along with her Lexus SUV after which drove away and let him die within the snowstorm.

An post-mortem discovered the reason for his dying blunt-force trauma on the head and hypothermia. O’Keefe had cranium fractures, mind bleeding, swollen black eyes and cuts on his proper arm, however the forensic pathologist stored itself to name it a homicide, making the best way of dying indefinitely.

Dr. Daniel Wolfe, a witness knowledgeable, testified that the harm to the rear finish of the car of Learn was not per hitting a human head or arm. Prosecutors attempt to have his testimony excluded the second time.

Follow the Fox True Crime Team on X

Karen Learn is within the doorway whereas she waits to depart Norfolk Superior Courtroom. (John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe by way of Getty Pictures)

His title continued to be unveiled on a witness of 150 folks on Monday, along with that of Michael Proctor, the previous lead researcher who was dismissed this month from the Massachusetts State Police.

Go right here for full protection of the 2nd Karen Learn Trial

Learn the witness record: cell customers Click here

The next is a timeline of vital occasions within the case:

January 28, 2022

Learn and O’Keefe went out in Canton, Massachusetts, a suburb of Boston about 15 miles from the town.

Though SMS messages launched through the course of they’d argued that morning, they went out collectively round 9 p.m. at CF McCarthy’s, an Irish bar. Round 11 they met pals and acquaintances within the waterfall bar and grille. The bar closed at midnight.

Jury member in Karen Mistrial joins her protection workforce for a brand new one

See McCarthy’s in Canton, Mass. (Richard Beetham for Fox Information Digital)

January 29, 2022

The then police officer Brian Albert Uit-Boston invited a bunch of individuals in his home at FairView Street for an after-party when the bar was employed. This may very well be the final time that O’Keefe was seen alive in public.

Jury member in Karen Mistrial joins her protection workforce for a brand new one

Early hours of January 29

• 12 hours: O’Keefe and Learn are invited to Albert’s home and a directions are given. However witnesses have testified that they by no means got here in.
• 12:37 am: studying reportedly leaves a voicemail with an expletive for O’Keefe and says, “John, I … hate you.” She was later accused of hitting him about 24 km / h after a backup of 60 toes in her car.
• 2:27 am: Jennifer McCabe is claimed to look on Google on how lengthy it takes to die within the chilly. She later testified that she was taking a look at Learn on the request.
• 6 hours: Learn again to the Alberts home with McCabe and one other particular person, and so they name 911 from outdoors, the place O’Keefe was discovered useless, based on a synopsis Van Courttvwho streamed the primary check.
• 6:23 AM: McCabe makes use of her cellphone to seek for details about dying within the chilly for the second time.

Register to get Actual crime publication

Karen Learn seems in Norfolk County Superior Courtroom for a listening to for the method. She is accused of deadly operating about her good friend, John O’Keefe, whose arm is proven with scratches and cuts on a poster in courtroom. (John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe by way of Getty Pictures)

See also  Astronauts reveal gut reaction to learning they weren’t coming home in exclusive interview

February 2, 2022

Learn was arrested on hit-and-run and manslaughter costs.

June 9, 2022

A substitute indictment accused of studying second -degree homicide.

Get actual -time updates immediately on the Actual crime hub

Decide Beverly Cannone presides for the jury’s choice through the Karen Learn Trial in Norfolk County Superior Courtroom, Thursday, April 18, 2024, in Dedham, Mass. (David McGlynn/New York Put up by way of AP, Pool)

April 16, 2024 to July 1

The primary check of Learn went out for weeks and ended with a hung jury. Decide Beverly Cannone declared a Mistrial.

Public prosecutors accused studying a drunk hit-and-run. Her protection argued that O

Officer John O’Keefe (Boston Police Division)

March 19, 2025

After months of inside investigation into the awkward textual content messages he learn within the first research, Proctor was fired from the Massachusetts State Police after a 12-year profession.

March 31

Concerning the eve of the jury selection for the second technique of Learn, Cannone has launched varied impactful statements concerning the case.

She rejected the try of the protection to witness a former FBI agent about failures to satisfy the police protocol with the primary investigation and restricted the scope of arguments that might improve the protection with regard to potential third events, together with Albert and ATF agent Brian Higgins, each of which have been current within the Waterfarbar.

ATF agent Brian Higgins speaks through the Karen Reader Trial in Norfolk Superior Courtroom, 28 Could 2024, in Dedham, Mass. (Stuart Cahill/Boston Herald by way of AP/Pool)

Click on right here to get the Fox Information app

The witness record additionally revealed that Proctor would take the place, even after his resignation, and so Aidan Kearney, an area blogger and a outstanding studying assistant who’s accused of witness intimidation.

April 1

Jury choice in Learn’s second check began in Dedham, Massachusetts.

The Related Press has contributed to this report.