Timeline issues could hurt case against Charlie Kirk’s accused assassin: lawyer

Provo, Utah – one of many biggest vulnerabilities within the case towards the accused assassin of Charlie Kirk, Tyler Robinson, could possibly be the timeline of the prosecutor, in accordance with a distinguished lawyer in Utah – and he or she expects the protection to be found within the case till he’ll lastly get a provisional listening to.

Kirk, a 31-year-old father of two, was shot and killed round 12:20 pm on 10 September whereas talking at a Turning Level USA occasion at Utah Valley College. He was a founding father of the conservative pupil group, who had a nationwide footprint and is credited for a revival of youth help for the Republican Social gathering.

“There may be simply a lot that we don’t but know if this case is growing,” says Skye Lazaro, from the corporate Salt Lake Metropolis, Ray Quinney & Nebeker.

The protection does not know a lot both. The invention course of began on Monday with a 5 -day deadline for public prosecutors to make their first disclosures, and the Robinson crew pushed his exemption a month in the past.

The homicide of Charlie Kirk leaves unanswered questions whereas researchers put collectively holes in case

Charlie Kirk throws hats to the gang after arrival at Utah Valley College on 10 September 2025 in Orem, Utah. (Trent Nelson/The Salt Lake Tribune/Getty pictures)

Any proof has already been made public, on information briefings, in feedback from authorities or paperwork submitted final week. Prosecutors embody rattling textual content messages between Robinson and his roommate and romantic accomplice, Lance Twiggs, during which he reportedly took accountability for the homicide of Kirk. However they don’t include time stamps.

Robinson, 22, was arrested 33 hours after the homicide in his hometown in South Utah. However earlier than that he returned to the crime scene, the place the police discovered the suspected homicide weapon, Fox Information Digital was the primary to report – however the authorities didn’t make the timing of his assembly with a police officer who’s stationed on the circumference.

“If it is not in line in a means that is smart, it could possibly definitely be dangerous for them,” Lazaro advised Fox Information Digital.

Robinson would have advised the officer that he needed to get one thing that he had left within the space of ​​a parking storage within the space – who can also be close by the place the police discovered the gun, in accordance with a supply of regulation enforcement. That was not instantly thought-about suspicious as a result of a whole bunch of individuals had dropped issues whereas they fled for security after Kirk’s demise for a crowd of about 3,000. However the officer did a routine management on the registration variety of Robinson, who related the authorities with the assembly after he was recognized as a possible suspect, in accordance with the supply.

The in depth protection crew of Charlie Kirk Assassination Suspect consists of the previous lawyer of Menendez Brother

Tyler Robinson seems virtually in Utah Court docket on September 16, 2025, to make accusations to the homicide of Charlie Kirk. (Utah State Courts)

If the officer’s bodycam just isn’t engaged, that could possibly be a gap for the protection of Robinson to attempt to poke holes within the investigation, Lazaro mentioned.

Further particulars in regards to the texts will also be extra dangerous to Robinson’s protection, Lazaro mentioned.

“Typically what you will get while you come throughout cellphones information are the place messages have been despatched,” she mentioned.

If the summons present that they had been despatched from Robinson’s cellphone in Orem and obtained by the phone from his accomplice in St. George, that might be consistent with the allegations of the prosecution.

Legal professionals of the protection Richard G. Novak, Michael N. Burt and Kathryn Nester, who characterize Tyler Robinson, the person accused of killing Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley College, seem throughout a listening to in Utah County Court docket in Provo, on Monday, 2025. (Laura Seitz/The Deseret Information by way of AP, Pool)

“The protection will wish to get, see, and possibly spend lots of time, whether or not they get their very own forensic consultants to research it or to do it themselves, to actually merge a timeline,” she added.

Twiggs works along with researchers, the authorities have mentioned. However the protection is predicted to do their greatest to undermine the state of the state.

Officers of the Utah will put together the doable demise penalty of the demise of Charlie Kirk suspected Tyler James Robinson

“It might probably come out that they aren’t as dangerous as they sound,” mentioned Lazaro. “You will have to bear in mind when the federal government writes a probable trigger, they’re their largest hits they’ve in the mean time.”

Gaps in what authorities have mentioned have additionally speculated on-line to hypothesis on-line, a big a part of which isn’t substantiated, and that won’t be a lot use for the protection, Lazaro added.

View: Suspected flight on the roof of the UVU Losee Middle Na Charlie Kirk Assassination

“There are some conspiracy theories about … Another person has written the SMS messages or one thing has been planted,” mentioned Lazaro. “As a lawyer, until you completely know and may show that one thing like that occurred, is that not the largest protection, proper? I believe you are likely to lose credibility until you’ll be able to actually substantiate it.”

The charging paperwork include nothing apologetic that the protection would attempt to use later. So they may search for these objects in discovery or by witness statements throughout a provisional listening to, which may nonetheless be a means, she mentioned.

Charlie Kirk’s alleged Murderer returns to courtroom – with out displaying his face

Researchers are searching for a recorded space in Orem, Utah, Thursday, September 11, 2025. (Derek shook for Fox Information Digital)

He has not but launched a plea. Throughout a distance declaration on Monday, the courtroom accepted two exterior the state of attorneys to assist his public defender of Utah, Kathy Nester. They’re Michael Burt and Richard Novak, each from California.

In Utah County, the place a big a part of the inhabitants is a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of the Saints of the final days and traveled rather a lot as a part of their mission work, she mentioned they didn’t count on their Golden State tires to be an impediment.

“If you happen to had been to do that case in East -Montana, I might say that it’s in all probability not helpful to have a big metropolis lawyer, as a result of folks do not love nice metropolis individuals who inform them what to do, or inform them how one can do their work or beat their police,” she mentioned. “I do not assume that is such an enormous drawback right here.”

Furthermore, their expertise with defending capital circumstances in a number of states and on the federal degree additionally exhibits that this isn’t the primary time that they needed to seem on behalf of a buyer like exterior the town, she mentioned.

What’s going to Tyler Robinson’s protection technique be? Specialists weigh on accused Charlie Kirk Murderer

A break up with 4 images of the particular person of curiosity within the homicide of Charlie Kirk on 10 September 2025 in Orem, Utah. (Utah Public Security)

The Ministry of Justice has not but introduced federal costs, however they continue to be a chance.

Nester requested the courtroom to resolve extra time to resolve whether or not Robinson will implement a provisional listening to, a proof -powerful listening to during which the prosecution is required to point out a probable trigger for the courtroom earlier than the case can proceed.

Though there is no such thing as a expectation that Robinson’s protection would have thrown the case throughout such a listening to, it might nonetheless give the protection a chance to discover a higher foot earlier than the process-such as a chance to analyze witnesses for the method and see how properly they carry out underneath intense questions.

“It’s a probably trigger, it’s in a light-weight that’s the most favorable for the state,” mentioned Lazaro.

In Utah, provisional hearings will be postponed for months in circumstances with critical crimes, typically as much as a 12 months, in accordance with Lazaro. Robinson is confronted with a high place of aggravated homicide, which carries the demise penalty, making it as critical because it turns into.

Click on right here to get the Fox Information app

His subsequent listening to is deliberate for October 30 in Provo, however Lazaro mentioned she anticipated his protection to ask for extra time once more.