Michigan’s newest ICE detention center draws scrutiny as it grows

By Ben Warren, MediaNews Group

The North Lake Processing Heart in west Michigan has solely been open a bit of greater than a month, but it surely already homes extra immigrants detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement than the remainder of the state’s detention facilities mixed, in accordance with figures reported by the Michigan Immigrant Rights Heart.

Republican lawmakers and GEO Group, the non-public firm that owns and operates North Lake close to Baldwin, tout the power’s potential to create jobs in Lake County — one among Michigan’s poorest — however immigration rights advocates have raised considerations about GEO’s human rights report and method to transparency.

Christopher Ferreira, the GEO Group’s director of company relations, defended the corporate’s work with ICE in an announcement to The Detroit Information, saying, “We’re happy with the position our firm has performed for 40 years to assist the regulation enforcement mission of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.”

He added, “In all situations, our assist providers are monitored by ICE, together with by on-site company personnel, and different organizations inside the Division of Homeland Safety to make sure strict compliance with ICE detention standards that set strict necessities on the remedy and providers ICE detainees obtain.”

North Lake formally opened on June 16 and now homes about 400 immigrants detained by ICE, mentioned Christine Sauve, who manages coverage and communications on the Michigan Immigrant Rights Heart. Because the facility is new, she mentioned, public-facing ICE databases aren’t updated. However an officer on the detention middle confirmed the variety of detainees to a personal lawyer who visited North Lake final month, in accordance with Sauvé.

GEO expects the consumption of ICE detainees to “progressively ramp up” by the second half of the yr, in accordance with an organization press launch, as President Donald Trump has vowed to hold out 1,000,000 deportations a yr in his second time period.

The Detroit area workplace of ICE, which oversees immigration enforcement in Michigan and Ohio, has detained greater than 3,000 folks by late July of this yr, greater than the workplace arrested throughout all of 2024, in accordance with knowledge tracked by the nationwide Data Deportation Project and analyzed by The Detroit Information.

“One of many limits at first of Trump’s time period and the beginning of his deportation program was that there weren’t sufficient amenities,” mentioned Richard Kessler, an immigration lawyer affiliated with the group No Detention Facilities Michigan.

“Now there’s tons of cash on the market, they’re going to fill these amenities.”

The 1,800-bed North Lake Processing Heart, closed since 2022, beforehand housed non-citizens who had dedicated federal crimes. ICE and GEO finalized a two-year contract for the operation of the North Lake facility on July 18, in accordance with a GEO press launch.

It’s by far the biggest of the 5 ICE detention facilities working in Michigan.

The others — the Calhoun County Correctional Heart, the Chippewa County Correctional Facility, the Monroe County Jail and the St. Clair County Jail — held a mixed 362 detainees as of Aug. 4, in accordance with figures made public on the ICE web site. All the amenities are underneath the jurisdiction of the ICE Detroit area workplace, which additionally oversees six detention facilities in Ohio.

GEO has a mixed 60,000 beds throughout 50 amenities in the US, in accordance with the corporate’s web site. ProPublica reported earlier this yr that 16 of those amenities had been getting used as ICE detention facilities.

The corporate stands to earn $85 million yearly from North Lake at full occupancy, in accordance with a GEO Aug. 6 press launch. ICE is GEO’s greatest buyer, paying for round one-third of the beds it operates in the US and producing practically 40% of its income, in accordance with monetary disclosures posted on the corporate’s web site in March.

One household’s expertise

North Lake has been the first vacation spot for Michigan residents detained by ICE in latest months.

One man being held within the facility is Nael Shamma, a 58-year-old Palestinian American who was residing in Burton, close to Flint, together with his spouse and son. Shamma entered the US 50 years in the past on a inexperienced card, but it surely was revoked in his 20s when he went to jail for assault.

He has attended annual check-ins with ICE since 2012, mentioned his niece, Sara Haddad, who advised The Information that the company’s makes an attempt to deport him that yr failed when Israeli officers wouldn’t log out. In recent times, he has labored by cleansing homes and taking good care of his aged mother and father.

An ICE spokesperson confirmed that Shamma is being held on the North Lake Processing Heart. In an e-mail to The Information, the spokesperson wrote: “Nael Shamma has a two-decade-long rap sheet to incorporate breaking and getting into, armed violence and aggravated battery. He freely admitted to ICE officers he ‘ran’ with the Latin Kings road gang in Chicago within the Eighties and has had a last order of removing since 1989.”

On Aug. 7, Haddad mentioned, Shamma was leaving house in his automotive when ICE brokers pulled him over and detained him.

“We had been all very scared,” Haddad mentioned, “as a result of we didn’t know the place they took him.” A number of days later, her aunt — Shamma’s spouse, Christina — came upon Shamma was being held at North Lake, about three hours from the couple’s house.

The interval when the household didn’t know his whereabouts “was horrifying,” Haddad mentioned. “It simply feels as if he was simply kidnapped.”

Christina Shamma has been capable of go to her husband as soon as, Haddad mentioned. She described North Lake as “a large jail” and advised Haddad that, at first, North Lake workers refused to provide Shamma the medicine he takes for top ldl cholesterol and insomnia.

The ICE spokesperson mentioned, “It’s a longstanding apply to supply complete medical care from the second an alien enters ICE custody,” however didn’t touch upon Shamma’s entry to medicine.

Haddad mentioned her uncle was just lately given a bit of paper to signal on the facility that she believes is a self-deportation order. She mentioned the power workers pressured him to signal it.

Fearful on the prospect of being deported to Israel, the place he may face persecution for his Palestinian background, Shamma refused to signal, Haddad mentioned. He does have household within the West Financial institution, his niece mentioned, however she is fearful he could be despatched to war-torn Gaza or a 3rd nation.

Sending Shamma to Gaza, the niece mentioned, “could be sending him to loss of life.”

“It’s been very, very onerous on everybody,” Haddad mentioned. “We love him a lot, and he actually helps maintain everybody.”

Shamma has 4 youngsters and two grandchildren, Haddad mentioned in a publish connected to a web based petition calling for his launch.

The ICE spokesperson indicated that the company would possibly ship Shamma to a 3rd nation: “When an immigration choose orders an alien eliminated to a rustic that won’t settle for them, ICE coordinates with the State Division to search for a 3rd nation that may.”

Immigration advocates elevate considerations

Immigrant rights teams expressed concern about GEO Group’s report of operating the North Lake facility and different detention facilities throughout the nation.

From 2019 to 2022, the GEO Group operated North Lake on a contract with the Federal Bureau of Prisons, holding non-citizens who had dedicated federal crimes. JR Martin, who belongs to a gaggle opposing the power, No Detention Facilities Michigan, mentioned the situations inside North Lake had been treacherous for detainees, particularly in the course of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“The pandemic was dealt with very badly,” Martin mentioned. The power’s insurance policies in the course of the early months of the pandemic led to inmates staging a number of starvation strikes, Interlochen Public Radio reported in Might 2020. The strikers claimed North Lake workers ignored an unsafe and chaotic surroundings and denied them entry to essential authorized mail.

Each GEO and the Bureau of Prisons denied {that a} starvation strike occurred.

GEO has additionally been the topic of lawsuits at its different detention facilities — in California for alleged sexual abuse and harassment by its workers, and in Washington and Colorado for allegedly violating minimal wage legal guidelines.

Final yr, members of California’s congressional delegation referred to as on the federal authorities to finish its contracts with GEO in that state, citing civil liberties complaints, experiences that detainees had been denied entry to attorneys and starvation strikes.

“Due to what we witnessed when North Lake was open from 2019-2022, and what we learn about GEO Group and ICE on the whole, I believe there’s each purpose to be very involved for folks’s security,” Martin mentioned.

The GEO Group spokesperson defended its operations and remedy of detainees.

“At places the place GEO offers well being care providers, people are supplied with sturdy entry to groups of medical professionals, together with physicians, nurses, dentists, psychologists, and psychiatrists,” the spokesperson mentioned.

Well being care staffing on the firm’s ICE detention facilities is “greater than double” most states’ correctional amenities, the corporate mentioned.

An ICE spokesperson added, “Any allegations that detainees will not be receiving medical care or situations are ‘inhumane’ are FALSE. All detainees are supplied with correct meals, medical remedy, and have alternatives to speak with legal professionals and their relations.”

No Detention Facilities Michigan members voiced their considerations at a July 4 protest, organizing an indication of greater than 200 folks outdoors of the North Lake facility in Baldwin.

The Michigan chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union is among the many teams advocating for stronger oversight of the North Lake Processing Heart.

“This detention facility is simply a part of the mass deportation scheme that’s ensuing within the separation of households, of group members being ripped out of locations they’ve lived for a very long time,” mentioned Ewurama Appiagyei-Dankah, a authorized fellow on the Michigan ACLU.

“I believe that this facility simply is antithetical to Michigan values.”

Appiagyei-Dankah referred to as for members of Michigan’s congressional delegation to go to the North Lake Processing Heart and be sure that the power is offering applicable interpretation providers, entry to authorized counsel and medical care.

“We’re hoping that members of Congress in Michigan will present that oversight,” she mentioned.

U.S. Rep. Hillary Scholten, D-Grand Rapids, mentioned she would “proceed to intently monitor developments on the North Lake Correctional Facility and elsewhere to make sure that detainees are being handled with dignity.”

“As we work to uphold our immigration legal guidelines, we should steadiness regulation enforcement with humanitarian considerations,” she mentioned in an announcement to The Information.

Republicans advocated for ICE facility

When North Lake was closed by govt order in 2022, two Republican congressmen from Michigan — John Moolenaar of Caledonia and Invoice Huizenga of Holland — despatched a letter to ICE’s director asking for steerage on turning the power into an ICE detention middle.

Within the letter, the congressmen wrote, “It’s vitally essential for the Midwest area to have the capability and amenities to maintain our communities secure and harmful criminals off the road. The North Lake Correctional Facility could possibly be extraordinarily helpful to ICE to perform these objectives.”

Jacob Huner, Moolenaar’s communications director, confirmed that the congressman contacted each the Division of Homeland Safety and representatives of the GEO Group about reopening the North Lake facility as an ICE detention middle.

Huner advised The Information that the power was the biggest non-public employer in Lake County earlier than the Biden administration ordered its closure in 2022.

“The middle’s re-opening may have a significant affect on the native economic system by bringing much-needed jobs again to rural Michigan,” he wrote.

Moolenaar doesn’t share the considerations of the ACLU or the protesters, however he “will proceed to watch the work executed on the North Lake Processing Heart,” Huner mentioned.

The GEO Group and ICE didn’t reply to a request to reveal the variety of folks the power employs.

Native authorities officers contacted by The Information concerning the facility declined to remark, together with Theresa Lamb, village of Baldwin clerk, and Tobi Lake, Lake County administrator.

Jodi Nichols, govt director of the Lake County Financial Growth Alliance, a volunteer-led nonprofit that helps financial and group progress, advised The Information by way of textual content message, “I don’t have any info to share on that venture.”

Appiagyei-Dankah mentioned the true financial affect of reopening North Lake may be underwhelming.

She mentioned the corporate portrays itself as “these good group stewards,” promising to spend money on the encircling group and create jobs. However in actuality, Appiagyei-Dankah mentioned, “they not often truly rent folks from the communities the place they open their amenities.”

bwarren@detroitnews.com

©2025 The Detroit Information. Go to detroitnews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.