Mysterious crimes shatter serenity in Hamptons and Montauk over decades

Within the customized Serene New York Seasing of the Hamptons and Montauk, a sequence of brutal crimes has sometimes shattered the peace.

From the richness -in 2001 financier Ted Ammon in 2001 in Montauk Parks in 2019, and now a mysterious demise on board a ship within the famend Montauk Yacht Membership, the area has seen a scattering of violent crimes in latest many years.

Though the mysterious demise of Martha Nolan is the newest to rattle the solar -drenched serenity of the area, it’s removed from the one disturbing incident in latest many years to disturb life within the Hamptons.

Irish magnificence that bikinis offered who had been discovered lifeless on the boat at Luxurious Yacht Membership, Policide Cops Probe

Martha Nolan, 33, owned a swimwear firm primarily based in Manhattan, New York. Her model contained high-end bikinis. (Fb/ Martha Nolan)

Bikini Model – founder – August 2025

On Tuesday, the visitors of the picturesque peninsula had been turned the wrong way up by the invention of 33-year-old Martha Nolan-O’Slatarra. In keeping with the Suffolk County police, the town officers of East Hampton responded to a name of 911 simply after midnight of a person who reported a girl unconscious on a ship moored on the luxurious marina, positioned on Star Island Highway.

Close by Good Samaritans tried resuscitation earlier than the primary response arrived, however the girl was declared lifeless on the spot, the police mentioned.

On Wednesday, the police recognized the deceased as Nolan, a diligent entrepreneur. They mentioned that her demise “didn’t present any proof of violence.” Authorities mentioned that the provisional investigation and the medical examination had been “not convincing” about the reason for demise.

An official assertion might be made after an post-mortem by the workplace of the Suffolk County Medical Examiner.

Unique enclave on the water fluctuated after the physique discovered close to the yacht membership

Initially from Carlow, Eire, Nolan was the founding father of East X East, a label of the boutique resort put on that she usually promoted Faucet As a result of trendy glimpse behind the scenes of her photograph shoots and design course of.

Generic view of Montauk Lighthouse and Seaside in Lengthy Island, New York. (Istock)

See also  Verdict in for substitute teacher charged with sex crimes against students

Love Triangle Homicide – June 2019

Within the early hours of 6 June 2019, the sleepy calmness of Montauk was pierced by the demise of 38-year-old Robert Casado.

In keeping with the Suffolk County District Attorney’s OfficeCasado, a seasonal employee, anticipated him to fulfill somebody for a job. As an alternative, the authorities mentioned, he was ambushed in an ambush by Joseph Grippo, a 47-year-old Montauk-Locale with a 36-inch Houweel grip on Kirk Park Path in Montauk.

Grippo Bludgeoned Casado lifeless, delivered a number of strokes with the improvised weapon and fled earlier than the police arrived. There was a love triangle motif because the main idea after prosecutors revealed that each Casado and Grippo had been concerned with the identical girl.

Joseph Grippo, 50, was accused in 2022 of manslaughter within the first diploma after he had crushed the love of the love of an ex-girlfriend earlier than demise. Grippo is now confronted with 20 years in jail plus 5 years after the discharge supervision of the indictment for manslaughter. (Suffolk County Police Division)

In keeping with public prosecutors, Grippo had cherished resentment for months. Prosecutors found that Grippo had deliberate the deadly assault for months and had purchased the improvised homicide weapon months earlier than.

After an intense native investigation and for nearly three years authorized backwards and forwards, Grippo responsible of first diploma manslaughter in July 2022. He was sentenced to twenty years in jail, with 5 further years after launch.

Suffolk County District Lawyer Ray Tierney referred to as the regulation “a chilly, calculated plan to kill a person he lured in a distant space below false pretenses.”

Reverse left to proper, Amber Lynn Costello, 27, Maureen Brainard barnes, 25, Megan Waterman, 22, and Melissa Barthelemy, 24, disappeared after a gathering with a buyer on Craigslist. The stays of the ladies had been present in December 2010 on Gilgo Seaside on Lengthy Island. (Suffolk County Police Division)

Our bodies within the Duinen: The Gilgo Seaside Murders – 2010

What began as a case of a lacking particular person within the spring of 2010 can be accomplished in one of the crucial disturbing investigations into serial homicide. When 24-year-old Shannan Gilbert disappeared after fleeing the home of a buyer in Oak Seaside, the Suffolk County police initially suspected that she had drowned in close by marsh land. Nevertheless, whereas researchers searched the comb previous Ocean Parkway, they’ve excavated 4 our bodies in Jute.

The ladies had been later recognized as Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Costello and Maureen Brainard -Barnes. All of them marketed escort providers on-line. The press referred to as them the “Gilgo 4”.

View ‘Architect of Death: The Long Island Serial Killer’ on Fox Nation

Within the following months, further units had been found, together with Valerie Mack, Jessica Taylor, Tanya Jackson and her Toddler Daughter Tatiana, and an individual who is barely referred to “Asian Doe” for years.

Rex Heermann seems within the courtroom of Decide Tim Mazze together with his lawyer, Michael Brown, on the Suffolk County Courtroom in Riverhead, New York, on Wednesday 12 March 2025. (James Carbone/NewDay by way of Pool)

The discoveries have fueled hypothesis of a attainable serial killer. The investigation stabbed till, in July 2023, the police arrested the 59-year-old Rex Heermann.

Heermann, a 59-year-old architect from Massapequa Park, was accused of the murders on Barthelemy, Waterman and Costello, and later referred to as the principle suspect within the homicide of Brainard barnes. Researchers used cell phone information, burner phone exercise, DNA forensic analysis and surveillance pictures to cost him.

By 2024, prosecutors added extra expenses and accused Heermann of luring victims to his home and killing them in his soundproof cellar. Heermann has not responsible of all expenses. He stays in custody whereas public prosecutors insist on a course of.

Aviation from the house base of financier Ted Ammon on 59 Center Lane in East Hampton, Lengthy Island, New York. Ammon was discovered there in 2001; Daniel Pelosi is now being accused of the homicide. (Mark Bonifacio/NY Each day Information Archive by way of Getty Photographs)

Register to get the true crime publication

Wall Avenue Financier Homicide – October 2001

In October 2021, the recent autumn air of Oost -Hampton was pierced by the Bluugone Loss of life of Ted Ammon, a Wall Avenue Financier. Ammon was discovered bare in his bed room on 59 Center Lane, his property in East Hampton.

His driver, arrival after Ammon had missed a enterprise assembly, found the scene: a high-tech alarm system was deactivated, there have been no indicators of compelled entrance or theft, and his physique wore 30-35 wounds.

Follow the Fox True Crime Team on X

Within the middle of the homicide investigation, the separation of Ammon of Generosa Ammon, with whom he had adopted twins from Ukraine in 1992. Generosa, within the midst of controversial divorce procedures, had employed Daniel Pelosi, an electrician and contractor, to work at her city corridor in Manhattan.

Daniel Pelosi in and round his home and spends quiet time serious about his authorized issues. (John Roca/NY Each day Information by way of Getty Photographs)

Daniel Pelosi was convicted of second -degree homicide in 2004 and sentenced to 25 years to life in jail, the place he stays. (John Roca/NY Each day Information by way of Getty Photographs)

Click on right here to get the Fox Information app

Their friendship flourished into an affair. After the homicide of Ammon, eyebrows had been lifted by the speedy marriage of Generosa and Pelosi.

It took virtually three years earlier than the case culminated in a conviction. Pelosi was arrested in March 2004 and later convicted of second -degree homicide and he obtained a punishment from 25 to life.

Generosa died of breast most cancers in August 2003 and the adopted twins inherited most of their father’s property, estimated within the tens of thousands and thousands, whereas Pelosi remained locked up.

Pelosi later claimed that he was the autumn man within the homicide investigation.

“I did not do it,” Pelosi informed Piers Morgan ‘The Killer Interview’ by Fox Nation. “I did not do that homicide. I did not kill Ted Ammon.”