Renee Good killed in ICE protest sparks civil disobedience debate

There appears to be some confusion in our society currently about what “civil disobedience” is and what it isn’t. Final week, this confusion brought on the dying of 37-year-old Renee Good.

Political protest within the type of civil disobedience has an extended and really proud custom, from Mahatma Gandhi who nonviolently challenged the British in India, to our personal Martin Luther King Jr. who wrote his eloquence from a jail cell in Birmingham.

There’s a stoic dignity on this observe, which in itself lends a seriousness and deep humility to the phrases of its practitioners.

What we’re seeing throughout the nation as organized gangs of wine mothers use Antifa techniques to harass and impede Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers isn’t civil disobedience. It isn’t even a protest. It is simply crime.

MINNEAPOLIS ICE SHOOTING OFFICER TOOK TRAINING BECAUSE A POSSIBLE ‘LETHAL THREAT’ WAS DRIVEN TO HIM: FORMER COPY

The phrase “civil” in civil disobedience refers to the truth that the demonstrators permit themselves to be arrested to emphasise how vital their trigger is to them. It’s also typically performed in a context that threatens minimal hurt to police and bystanders.

At present, throughout the nation, however particularly in strongholds of democratic socialism like Minneapolis, Portland, and Seattle, we’re seeing one thing very totally different: teams of individuals following, harassing, doxxing, and generally immediately attacking ICE brokers.

Renee Nicole Good moments earlier than she was shot and killed by a federal agent in Minneapolis. (Obtained by Fox Information)

See also  DHS fires back at Rep. Grijalva’s pepper-spray claim during Tucson ICE raid

What these ICE Watch teams throughout the nation, of which Good was reportedly a educated member, are doing could be very totally different. They’re making an attempt to cease federal brokers from implementing democratically enacted legal guidelines with out sending a message, and extra importantly, they’re making an attempt to evade seize.

NOEM commends DHS officers on Regulation Enforcement Appreciation Day as assaults on federal brokers improve nationwide

Sorry, that is a criminal offense, not a protest.

Moreover, we should ask very severely whether or not teams of people that prepare after which perform missions that endanger regulation enforcement and the general public could in truth be prison conspirators.

In case your job is to look out for a road drug commerce within the neighborhood, that is a criminal offense. It isn’t completely clear why doing the identical to guard unlawful immigrants, a lot of whom are vicious criminals, isn’t a comparable exercise.

ANTI-ICE WORKERS THREATEN AGENTS IN CHAOTIC MINNESOTA PROTESTS: ‘YOU’RE GOING TO DIE’

In response to a current ballot, solely 24% of Individuals imagine it’s acceptable to transcend peaceable protest in response to ICE enforcement. However amongst white girls ages 18 to 44, that quantity jumps to an astonishing 61%.

Possibly they take heed to too many true crime podcasts, however we have now to ask ourselves: How on earth did this grow to be acceptable conduct in our society?

The brief reply is that for many of this century, our regulation enforcement companies and courts have merely allowed this to occur. They’ve determined that some prison exercise is ok, so long as your trigger is simply.

ICE OFFICER WHO SHOT WOMAN IN MINNESOTA WAS SLAUGHT BY ILLEGAL ALIEN SEX OFFENDER’S CAR MONTHS EARLIER

This typically begins with violations of the regulation that border on foolishness, like throwing a Subway sandwich at a cop, however then the sandwich turns into a snowball, then a lock, and earlier than you recognize it, persons are hitting federal brokers with SUVs.

The video of Good and her associate harassing and, let’s face it, goading ICE brokers with an obnoxious smugness that may make most individuals’s pores and skin crawl is only one of many.

We see these self-righteous white girls doing it in video after video after video, mocking police, insulting journalists, and even bystanders, typically with an odd and disturbing glee.

DEM NARRATIVE CHALLENGED AFTER DHS USES IDENTITY OF ‘MARRIED COUPLE’ IN CBP-RELATED SHOOTINGS

Let’s be clear: this occurs as a result of we make it occur. The place I reside in West Virginia, if I noticed {that a} state trooper had pulled over a pal of mine and determined to throw issues on the officer, I’d be rightfully arrested. So why are the principles totally different in case you’re towards ICE?

Individuals protest the deadly taking pictures of Renee Nicole Good throughout a rally outdoors the Whipple Constructing on January 8, 2026 in Minneapolis. (Tim Evans/Reuters)

The accountable factor each Democrat in politics and within the media should do as we speak and now’s inform their viewers that it’s by no means okay to assault a cop, that it’s by no means okay to impede a federal investigation, and that they need to cease it.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS ADVICE

As a substitute, Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., stood as much as a Minnesota crowd on Friday from the again of a pickup truck and stated, “You’ve all been pushing that this resistance isn’t one thing that may be intimidated.” If she was referring to utilizing automobiles to thwart federal brokers, as she seemed to be doing, then that’s merely a name for revolt.

CHAD WOLF, COOPER SMITH: MAYOR FREY, ICE DOES NOT SOW CHAOS. YOU ARE. PLEASE REDUCE

Actually, there are good causes to imagine that anybody who would say that shouldn’t be in Congress.

Sadly, Democrats won’t do the accountable factor even when they shield their very own supporters like Good who ought to nonetheless be alive as we speak.

No, there is just one reply right here; implementing the regulation.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

And this is my warning: If we do not implement the regulation, if we merely permit these cosplaying so-called revolutionaries to do no matter they need, together with hitting cops with automobiles, Renee Good will not be the final to die needlessly.

This insanity should finish, and it should finish now.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM DAVID MARCUS